Choir with bass and drums, can it work?

I was wondering why some choirs, when touring with two-piece band, go for piano+drums, as opposed to bass+drums. Piano can play bass notes, but the piano+drums setup leaves the overall sound not as full as a dedicated bass instrument.

Any choir, when singing á capella, will drop in pitch over the course of a song. Even the brilliant Perpetuum Jazzile . Try playing along to e.g. Mas Que Nada, and you’ll see that they drop at least a semitone. It’s a gradual process over a few minutes, rather hard to spot by an unguided ear.

When there’s a piano or guitar playing with the choir, it’ll help the choir hold the pitch. I thought that bass guitar would do that as well. It sounded so good as an idea: you can have a piano trio or a guitar trio, with one main harmonic instrument and a rhythm section. Choir is a type of a harmonic instrument, so all it needs is a rhythm section! Therefore, bass+drums+choir should work great.

It turns out, this combination doesn’t work out. The bass guitar does not in practice help the choir hold the pitch. One explanation could be that it’s generally hard to hear the pitch of low notes. I tried to play higher notes, but it still didn’t help. The idea of a choir with a rhythm section doesn’t work.

UPDATE 2012-07-24: I got a good effect by playing chords in some parts of the song (somewhere up the neck) and bass notes elsewhere. For instance, I’d play chords in the verse, and bass notes in the chorus. It was effective.

Author: automatthias

You won't believe what a skeptic I am.